In the end, Rachel McGill’s custard just didn’t set up. Some might blame the camel milk she was required to use. Or the blast freezer not blasting enough frost.
The Lincoln chef, making her Food Network debut on “Chopped,” says she just ran out of time.
As a result, her squash and camel milk custard with a gooseberry garnish and fortune cookie crumble — while tasty, the three judges agreed — was chopped.
And McGill, the executive chef and co-owner of Dish and the only James Beard award nominee ever from Lincoln, had to settle for second place in the popular cooking show.
People are also reading…
“I just really didn’t want to be first out,” said McGill, who survived the appetizer and entrée rounds to advance to the final round — a dessert.

A crowd watches Lincoln chef Rachel McGill's appearance on "Chopped" Tuesday night in The Railyard.
“Chopped,” which debuted in 2009, pits four chefs against each other in a cooking contest that requires them to think on their feet by using random ingredients — placed in a basket — while cooking against the clock.
She earned praise from the judging panel, most notably Maneet Chauhan, an Indian chef and regular “Chopped” judge who has a tendency to be hard on the contestants.
Chauhan complimented McGill’s cooking skills and her imagination, calling her the chef to beat in the competition.
“I was looking forward to like having her as a judge,” McGill said. “I knew she was pretty, pretty hard and difficult to please. I also knew it would be a good showing for sure if I did well with her.”
Her three baskets of ingredients had some unknowns — watermelon radishes in the appetizer round and the aforementioned camel milk in the dessert round — but nothing she couldn’t handle.
“It wasn’t crazy,” she said. “I felt like I prepared myself mentally for anything. I thought I might have to break down a whole fish or have to do something really strange, but they really didn’t mess with us that hard.”
For those wondering, camel milk has a different taste than the more commonly used dairy products used in America, McGill said.
“It’s kind of gamey,” she said. “It’s got a very, very distinct flavor. It’s also really thick.”
McGill said she watched the show on Tuesday downtown with friends, but made an appearance at the Railyard, where her parents and hundreds of community members were watching the show on The Cube.
“It was weird to see my face that big,” she said. “The amount of support from the community was really, really amazing. It was really humbling.
“They gave me a cheer when I came in.”
The 10 longest-running restaurants in Lincoln
1942: Lee's Restaurant

Lee's Restaurant, shown in 2014 when the mascot Pete was welcomed home after being stolen, is Lincoln's oldest full-service restaurant. It is located at 1940 W. Van Dorn.
1957: Valentino's

Valentino's, the second-oldest restaurant, has multiple locations in Lincoln. The restaurant chain got started on Holdrege in 1957.
1963: Misty's

Misty's (the sign for the original at 6235 Havelock is shown) is Lincoln's third-oldest restaurant.
1965: Virginia's Travelers Cafe

Virginia's Travelers Cafe at 3280 Cornhusker Highway is Lincoln's fourth-oldest full-service restaurant. In this picture, Rich "Rob" Robinson eats breakfast at Virginia's in 2008.
1976: Tico’s

Tico's, 317 S. 17th St., is Lincoln's fifth-oldest full-service restaurant.
1978: daVinci's

DaVinci's has multiple Lincoln locations, all serving pizza, pasta and sandwiches. The Knudson family began their restaurant business in Lincoln in 1978 with Pontillo's Pizzeria downtown. The first daVinci's location opened in 1984 on South 48th Street.
1982: Piezano's

Piezano's, 2740 South St., is Lincoln's sixth-oldest restaurant. In this photo, Shawn Watters takes down a ticket at Piezano's on Super Bowl Sunday in 2016.
1984: The Isles

Isles Pub & Pizza, 6232 Havelock Ave., tied for seventh-oldest full-service restaurant in Lincoln.
1986: Billy's

Billy's Restaurant, 1301 H St., is Lincoln's ninth-oldest restaurant.
1988: Hi-Way Diner

Lincoln's Hi-Way Diner, 2105 Nebraska 2, has plenty of homestyle favorites such as meatloaf on the menu. The restaurant opened in 1988.